Skip to main content
Healthfirst logo

Fraud Examiner

Healthfirst

New York, NYJob$49–64K/yrSeen 1 day agoIn the employer's feed · checked in the last 2 days

See where you stand before you apply. No sign-up to start.

You apply on the posting's application page, with no Olive account needed.

Watch jobs like this.

Don't just apply. Show up ready.

Olive works from this exact posting.

At a glance

Compensation
$49–64K/yr
Location
New York, NY
Work Authorization
Not specified

Olive focuses on jobs in the United States, including remote roles you can work from there.

Requirements

Credentials this posting asks for.

Associate's degree, required

Job overview

The Fraud Examiner supports Healthfirst’s Special Investigations Unit by processing healthcare claims and financial information, coordinating agency requests and restricted-recipient communications, and assisting investigators with interviews and investigative follow-up. The role also supports committee meetings and records decisions. Candidates need an associate degree, data analysis experience, and prior insurance-claims investigation, audit, or other professional investigations experience. A bachelor’s degree and experience with Tableau or SAS are preferred.

Skills & qualifications

RequiredNice to have

Skills

Microsoft Word, requiredMicrosoft Outlook, requiredMicrosoft Excel, requiredData Analysis, requiredInsurance Claims Investigation, requiredInsurance Claims Audit, requiredProfessional Investigations, requiredCritical Thinking, requiredAnalytical Skills, requiredTeamwork, requiredOral Communication, requiredWritten Communication, requiredData Summarization, requiredInvestigative Reporting, requiredTableau, nice to haveSAS, nice to haveMedicare, nice to haveMedicaid, nice to haveHealthcare Claims Data, nice to haveMedical Claims Processing, nice to haveMedical Claims Investigations, nice to haveMedical Records Reading, nice to haveFraud Statutes, nice to haveCMS Guidelines, nice to haveInsurance Reporting Requirements, nice to haveSpanish, nice to haveOther Languages, nice to have

Qualifications

Associate Degree, requiredData Analysis Experience, requiredInsurance Claims Investigation, Audit, or Professional Investigations Experience, requiredBachelor's Degree, nice to have

Benefits

Medical Insurance
Dental Insurance
Vision Insurance
401(k) Match

Full job description

  • Synthesize, analyze and process healthcare claims data and financial information in Excel, creation of tables/pivot tables for internal review and reporting

  • Support HF SIU FWA team by maintaining an Agency Referral Log of all incoming agency requests for information (RFI)

  • Obtain necessary information in response to RFIs to present to legal department for approval

  • Monitor Restricted Recipient Program (RRP) by notifying appropriate departments of incoming informational packets

  • Mailing of information regarding RRP to members

  • Coordinate member and provider packets for members restricted by Member Review and Restriction Committee;

  • Monitors internal mailboxes for incoming investigative inquiries

  • Assist investigators with interviews, review of information and determination for further investigative steps; assist with Marketing Incidents Committee Meeting by attending meetings and managing notes and minutes, update Marketing Log with MIC decisions and directives

  • Assist SIU colleagues with Fraud, Waste and Abuse issues and problem solve

  • Additional duties as assigned, including but not limited to minor administrative tasks in support of the department will be a requirement of this position

Minimum Qualifications:

  • AA/AS degree from an accredited institution

  • Intermediate Word and Outlook skills

  • Intermediate/Advanced Excel skills including pivot tables and basic formulas

  • Data analysis experience

  • Prior experience in either insurance claims investigation/audit or other professional investigations

  • Critical thinking, analytical skills and teamwork experience

  • Good oral and written communication skills including an ability to summarize data analysis and contribute to investigative reports

Preferred Qualifications:

  • Bachelors Degree from an accredited institution

  • Experience with Tableau and/or SAS

  • Knowledge of Medicare and Medicaid and/or healthcare claims data

  • Knowledge of medical claims processing and investigations and the ability to read medical records

  • Knowledgeable about applicable fraud statutes, regulations, CMS guidelines, Federal and State insurance reporting requirements.

  • Professional conduct in dealing with persons internal and external to the organization

  • Spanish or other language proficiency

Compliance & Regulatory Responsibilities: N/A

License/Certification: N/A

Hiring Range*:

Greater New York City Area (NY, NJ, CT residents): $48,600 - $64,480

All Other Locations (within approved locations): $42,200 - $62,400

As a candidate for this position, your salary and related elements of compensation will be contingent upon your work experience, education, licenses and certifications, and any other factors Healthfirst deems pertinent to the hiring decision.

In addition to your salary, Healthfirst offers employees a full range of benefits such as, medical, dental and vision coverage, incentive and recognition programs, life insurance, and 401k contributions (all benefits are subject to eligibility requirements). Healthfirst believes in providing a competitive compensation and benefits package wherever its employees work and live.

*The hiring range is defined as the lowest and highest salaries that Healthfirst in “good faith” would pay to a new hire, or for a job promotion, or transfer into this role.

WE ARE AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER. Applicants and employees are considered for positions and are evaluated without regard to mental or physical disability, race, color, religion, gender, gender identity, sexual orientation, national origin, age, genetic information, military or veteran status, marital status, mental or physical disability or any other protected Federal, State/Province or Local status unrelated to the performance of the work involved.

How this job compares

Set against the 454 open Investigator jobs on Olive Jobs, counted November 16, 2026.

Pay
  • This posting$49–64K/yr
  • New York median$70–89K/yr61 salary ranges
  • US median$70–107K/yr271 salary ranges

This range's midpoint, $57K, is 28% below the New York median midpoint ($79K) — in the lowest quarter of Investigator salary ranges in New York.

Openings
Olive Jobs lists 71 open Investigator jobs in New York and 454 across the US. 7% of them nationwide are listed as remote or flexible.
Hiring the most in New York
Experience
Investigator postings that state a minimum ask for 3 years of experience at the median; the middle half ask for 2 to 5 years (327 postings).
Education
This posting asks for an associate degree; 191 of the 454 open Investigator jobs (42%) ask for an associate degree or higher.

Counted across the open, public US postings on Olive Jobs on November 16, 2026. Figures based on too few postings are left out.

Prepare for this role

You've read the whole posting — now see how you match it.