Skip to main content
Five Star Bank logo

Fraud Risk Analyst I

Five Star Bank

Buffalo, NYFull-time$24–28/hrSeen todaySeen in employer's feed today

Most applications go out cold — see where you stand first. No sign-up to start.

You apply on the employer's site, with no Olive account needed.

Watch jobs like this.

Don't just apply. Show up ready.

Olive works from this exact posting.

At a glance

Compensation
$24–28/hr
Location
Buffalo, NY
Schedule
Full-time
Work Authorization
Not specified

Olive lists jobs from US employers, including remote roles you can work from the United States.

Job overview

The Fraud Analyst I reviews transaction alerts and investigates suspected fraud across the Bank’s channels, taking action to protect the Bank and its customers. The role uses Q2 Sentinel and other monitoring systems, includes direct customer outreach, and handles inquiries from staff and customers. The analyst also tracks fraud trends and develops expertise in monitoring-system reporting, scenario optimization, and model validation.

Skills & qualifications

RequiredNice to have

Skills

Fraud Investigation, requiredFraud Trend Analysis, requiredVerbal Communication, requiredWritten Communication, requiredOrganization, requiredPrioritization, requiredIssue Response, requiredData Interpretation, requiredAttention to Detail, requiredMicrosoft Applications, requiredBanking Software, requiredInternet Research, requiredQ2 Sentinel, nice to haveProlonged Sitting, requiredProlonged Standing, required

Qualifications

High School Diploma, required3+ Years Anti-Fraud Experience, requiredBachelor's Degree, nice to have3+ Years Financial Services Anti-Fraud Experience, nice to haveCertified Fraud Examiner or CAFP or Other Anti-Fraud Certification, nice to have

Benefits

Medical Insurance
Dental Insurance
Vision Insurance
Tuition Assistance

Full job description

Regular Full-Time

Fraud

Buffalo, NY, US

Rochester, NY, US

Warsaw, NY, US

Requisition ID: 5639

Salary Range: $24.00 To $28.00 Hourly

Purpose : The Fraud Analyst I is tasked with conducting account reviews based on specific triggers to identify and prevent fraudulent transactions. This role also involves taking swift action to freeze funds or restrict accounts to protect the Bank and its customers from potential losses. The Fraud Analyst will utilize Q2 Sentinel software daily as their primary transaction monitoring system.

Essential Functions:

  • Reviews transaction monitoring alerts for fraudulent or unusual activity primarily using Q2 Sentinel as well as other transaction monitoring systems, recommending whether alerts should be escalated to case or cleared. Direct customer outreach is required for numerous alerts.

  • Monitors daily reports across multiple systems, that may include mobile check deposits, loan checks, ATM deposits, uncollected funds, employee credits, and digital banking transactions, to identify, halt, and report fraudulent activity across the Bank's channels.

  • Investigates escalated alerts and manually created cases (e.g., business unit referrals, negative news, vendor reports, etc.) for fraudulent or suspicious activity. Takes appropriate actions based on findings (e.g., referring suspicious activity to BSA, restricting/closing customer accounts/access, etc.). Direct customer outreach is required for cases.

  • Tracks and maintains departmental spreadsheets reflecting reported fraud risk and trend data for Management review.

  • Handles incoming phone calls from Branch staff, other business units, and customers related to fraud investigations or potentially fraudulent activities such as elder abuse referrals, identity theft reports, check verifications, and unusual transaction activity.

  • Develops into a subject matter expert in the Q2 Sentinel transaction monitoring system. This includes report generation, optimization of scenarios, etc., model validation, and other attributes that enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of the system.

  • Demonstrates the standards and principles of the Five Star Bank experience in every interaction with internal and external customers, associates, and stakeholders, incorporating high-performance behaviors of teamwork, leading by example, and service in all aspects of work.

Job Related Qualifications:

Required:

  • Education: High School Diploma

  • Prior Experience: 3+ years of anti-fraud experience

  • Licenses or Accreditation: Any required licenses or accreditation required

Preferred:

  • Education: Bachelor’s Degree

  • Prior Experience: 3+ years of anti-fraud experience in the financial services industry

  • Licenses or Accreditation: Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE), Certified Anti-Money Laundering Fraud Professional (CAFP), or other Anti-Fraud Certifications

Competencies:

  • Knowledge of and ability to learn emerging fraud trends and tactics.

  • Strong verbal and written communication skills with the ability to convey pertinent information to all levels of staff and customers.

  • Strong organizational skills with the ability to manage multiple priorities and meet established deadlines.

  • Ability to respond quickly and effectively to issues involving high dollar or high-volume fraudulent transactions, irate customers, robberies, complaints and law enforcement interaction.

  • Ability to identify trends, interpret data and apply to workflows.

  • Possess a high level of attention to detail.

  • Proficient with Microsoft applications with the ability to learn and utilize new and existing banking software applications; ability to utilize the internet to conduct searches related to responsibilities.

  • Preferred: Q2 Sentinel Software

Physical Requirements:

  • Able to regularly sit for prolonged periods of time.

  • Able to regularly stand for prolonged periods of time.

  • Able to travel:

  • Occasionally

  • Extensive computer usage is required.

Benefits:

  • Medical, Dental, and Vision Insurance

  • Health Savings Account

  • Flexible Spending Account(s)

  • Company Paid Life Insurance, Long Term Disability, and Short Term Disability

  • Voluntary Offerings: Life, Critical Illness/Specified Disease, Accident, Hospital Indemnity & Personal Accident

  • Tuition Reimbursement

  • Employee Referral Program

  • Wellness Reimbursement Program

  • Star Volunteer Program

  • Employee Banking and Financial Perks

  • Paid Time Off (PTO)

  • Company Paid Holidays

This job description is not exhaustive. The Fraud Risk Analyst I may be required to perform other duties as assigned. The expected rate of pay for this position is shown above. Compensation offers are based on a wide range of factors including relevant skills, training, experience, education and, where applicable, licenses or certifications obtained. Market and organizational factors are also considered. In addition to your base rate of pay and a competitive benefits package, successful candidates may be eligible to receive cash or equity-based incentives based on the role and performance.

How this job compares

Set against the 826 open Risk Analyst jobs on Olive Jobs, counted November 10, 2026.

Pay
  • This posting$24–28/hr
  • US median$32–43/hr33 hourly ranges

This range's midpoint, $26/hr, is 31% below the US median midpoint ($38/hr) — in the lowest quarter of Risk Analyst hourly ranges across the US.

Openings
Olive Jobs lists 88 open Risk Analyst jobs in New York and 826 across the US. 9% of them nationwide are listed as remote or flexible.
Hiring the most in New York
Experience
This posting asks for at least 3 years of experience; Risk Analyst postings that state a minimum ask for 3 years at the median (645 postings).
Education
This posting asks for a high school diploma; 260 of the 826 open Risk Analyst jobs (31%) ask for a high school diploma or higher.

Counted across the open, public US postings on Olive Jobs on November 10, 2026. Pay medians are the middle values of the low ends and of the high ends of postings that list both ends of a range in the same cadence (a yearly salary or an hourly rate); a range's midpoint is halfway between its ends. Pay and experience figures resting on fewer than 20 postings are left out.

Prepare for this role

You've read the whole posting — now see how you match it.