Agri-Mark, Inc. logo

Butter Supervisor

Agri-Mark, Inc.

West Springfield, MAFull-time$70–85K/yrSeen 6 days agoSeen in employer's feed 6 days ago

Most applications go out cold — see where you stand first. No sign-up to start.

Watch jobs like this.

At a glance

Compensation
$70–85K/yr
Location
West Springfield, MA
Schedule
Full-time
Work Authorization
Not specified

Olive lists jobs from US employers, including remote roles you can work from the United States.

Job overview

The Butter Supervisor oversees all phases of the butter operation at Agri-Mark’s West Springfield facility. The role coordinates production schedules with the Master Scheduler, supports continuous improvement, guides and trains team members, and works with the Production Manager to meet regulatory and customer specifications. It also supports daily maintenance and laboratory functions, with safety as a priority. Additional hours beyond 40 and weekend or holiday rotations may be required.

Skills & qualifications

RequiredNice to have

Skills

Production SchedulingContinuous ImprovementSQFHACCPGMP

Qualifications

College Degree or Manufacturing Experience3-5 Years Related Experience3 Years Supervisory ExperienceFood Manufacturing Experience

Benefits

401(k) Match
Tuition Assistance

Full job description

Butter Supervisor Job Category: Manager & Supervisors Requisition Number: SUPER002429 Full-Time On-site Salary: $70,000 USD per year LocationsShowing 1 location West Springfield West Springfield, MA, USA Pay or shift range: $70,000 USD to $85,000 USD The estimated range is the budgeted amount for this position. Final offers are based on various factors, including skill set, experience, location, qualifications and other job-related reasons. Job Details Description How would we describe a career with Agri-Mark/McCadam/Cabot Creamery? More than 100 years of: Farmers, Family, Mission, Purpose, Sustainability, Respect, Integrity, Work Ethic, Teamwork, Pride in Award Winning Products and Agriculture! Cabot Creamery has held B Corp certification since 2012 and became the world's first dairy co-op to do so. This certification demonstrates our commitment to transforming the global economy to benefit all people, communities, and the planet. What you'll be doing: The Butter Supervisor is responsible for all phases of the butter operation at the West Springfield facility. The Butter Supervisor will assist the Master Scheduler to ensure work schedules are prepared in a manner to achieve production goals; Butter Supervisor will initiate/support/participate in continuous improvement initiatives with a focus on effectiveness and efficiencies. Establish and maintain effective working relationships with team member and provide guidance to trainees and coworkers. Provide support in ensuring that an adequately trained workforce is maintained. All butter team employees will report to the Butter Supervisor. Work with Production Manager to ensure all products meet regulatory and customer specifications. Support for daily maintenance and laboratory functions in support of production and quality goals is expected. All duties will be performed with safety in mind as a priority. Additional hours over 40 are required, participation in weekend and holiday rotations may also be required. What we are seeking: College degree or experience in manufacturing, dairy manufacturing preferred. 3-5 years related experience and/or training. Solid knowledge of SQF, HAACP and GMPs. Minimum 3 years supervisor experience in a food manufacturing environment or combination of education and related work experience considered. Pay range for this position is $70,000-$85,000/yr. This range is an expected starting range but may be negotiable for candidates who demonstrate additional qualifications and experience. Our support of employee growth includes promoting from within, training and tuition reimbursement. Team members enjoy access to a comprehensive benefits package, competitive salary and retirement plans which include 401k match. Agri-Mark is an equal opportunity employer. The company is committed to the fundamental principle of equal opportunity and equal treatment for every qualified prospective and current employee. The company does not discriminate or allow discrimination on the basis of race (including traits historically associated with race including hair texture and protective hairstyles), color, religion, ancestry, national origin, citizenship, genetic information, sex (including pregnancy or pregnancy-related conditions), sexual orientation, gender identity, place of birth, crime victim status, age, physical or mental disability, a positive result from an HIV-related blood test, military or veteran status, or any other classification protected under applicable federal and/or state law. Agri-Mark complies with all federal, state, and local laws and regulations.

How this job compares

Set against the 1,859 open Production Supervisor jobs on Olive Jobs, counted October 27, 2026.

Pay
  • This posting$70–85K/yr
  • Massachusetts median$82–100K/yr25 salary ranges
  • US median$73–99K/yr695 salary ranges

This range's midpoint, $78K, is 14% below the Massachusetts median midpoint ($90K) — in the lowest quarter of Production Supervisor salary ranges in Massachusetts.

Openings
Olive Jobs lists 38 open Production Supervisor jobs in Massachusetts and 1,859 across the US. Under 1% of them nationwide are listed as remote or flexible.
Hiring the most in Massachusetts
Experience
This posting asks for at least 3 years of experience; Production Supervisor postings that state a minimum ask for 3 years at the median (1,277 postings).
Education
165 of the 1,859 open Production Supervisor jobs (9%) ask for a bachelor's degree or higher.

Counted across the open, public US postings on Olive Jobs on October 27, 2026. Pay medians are the middle values of the low ends and of the high ends of postings that list both ends of a range in the same cadence (a yearly salary or an hourly rate); a range's midpoint is halfway between its ends. Pay and experience figures resting on fewer than 20 postings are left out.

Similar jobs, posted recently

Open roles like this one, listed in the last 30 days.

You've read the whole posting — now see how you match it.